The Royal Tenenbaums currently beats Isle of Dogs 60–40

The family saga edges the dog story.

VS
60% 40%
Based on 60 head-to-head votes across 1 bracket

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Director's Cut

Both are ensemble films about people cast out of a family, one on a Manhattan block and one on an exile island, and the live-action one has one plain advantage: faces. Hackman, Huston, Paltrow with the kohl eyes and the secret cigarettes, Luke Wilson in the headband, all doing the small human things an animator has to plan. Isle of Dogs answers with design and with Cranston's Chief, a stray voiced like a man who has been hit too often, and the island sets are among the most beautiful things Anderson has built. The Tenenbaums are allowed to be a mess, and Hackman is allowed to be worse.

The Numbers

The Royal Tenenbaums Isle of Dogs
Head-to-Head 60% 40%
Overall Win Rate 56% 41%
Championships 10 6
Avg Decision 4.5s 4.4s
Budget $21M $35M
Return 3.4x 2.1x

Where This Matchup Sits

Among Wes Anderson's 8 films on BingeBracket, The Royal Tenenbaums sits at #3 and Isle of Dogs at #5.

The Royal Tenenbaums (2001) and Isle of Dogs (2018) are 17 years apart, which makes raw box office comparisons misleading. Relative to their budgets, both returned a similar multiple — but The Royal Tenenbaums wins the head-to-head.