Sherlock Holmes poster

Sherlock Holmes

Gatekeeper Strong in semis, fades in finals
2009 · Action, Adventure, Crime, Mystery · Guy Ritchie

At 53%, Sherlock Holmes is among the better-performing films on BingeBracket. The final is where its record starts to slip — a pattern consistent enough across tournaments to define it. Ritchie's first blockbuster and still his most-watched franchise, with Robert Downey Jr. as a scruffy, fidgeting Holmes and Jude Law as the Watson who finally gets to be the grown-up. It's the one Ritchie title casual viewers have definitely seen, and that reach counts for a lot on a ballot.

Synopsis

Eccentric consulting detective Sherlock Holmes and Doctor John Watson battle to bring down a new nemesis and unravel a deadly plot that could destroy England.

Round 1
48.8%
41/84
Semifinals
70.7%
Where it thrives
Finals
37.9%
The ceiling

Close but not quite. 71% in the semis says genuine contender; 38% in the final says there's a gap between contending and winning that Sherlock Holmes hasn't closed.

The Gentlemen at 50% is as close to a dead heat as the platform produces. Every vote matters in this one. Wrath of Man is the easy matchup at 73%. Snatch is the kryptonite at 17%. The gap between best and worst opponent says a lot about what Sherlock Holmes can and can't handle.

Closest Rival
Dominates
Kryptonite
Snatch
83.3%

It's Been Emotional: Best of Guy Ritchie is Sherlock Holmes's bracket: it clears the early rounds consistently but meets its ceiling in the final against Snatch (17%).

Near the top of Guy Ritchie's 8-film lineup on BingeBracket. Snatch at 78% is the benchmark; Sherlock Holmes at #3 isn't far behind.

BingeBracket Record
53%
Win Rate
#24 of 61 in Action #20 of 52 from the 2000s #3 of 8 Guy Ritchie films
Scores based on real fan votes in head-to-head brackets. 50% = wins as often as it loses — perfectly average.
Featured Tournament

#3 of 8 in It's Been Emotional: Best of Guy Ritchie.

Think it deserves the gold? Cast your vote now.

Snatch #1
The Gentlemen #2
Sherlock Holmes #3
Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels #4
RocknRolla #5
The Man from U.N.C.L.E. #6
Wrath of Man #7
In the Grey #8
Vote Now
About These Rankings

BingeBracket ranks films through head-to-head matchups in 8-film brackets — no star ratings, no reviews, just direct comparison. Browse tournaments, try Discovery mode, or explore the leaderboards. You can also .

← Browse All Movies