The Exorcist currently dominates A Nightmare on Elm Street 68–32

Friedkin's documented possession outlasts Craven's dream spectacle.

VS
32% 68%
Based on 28 head-to-head votes across 1 bracket

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Decade Duel

Regan's head turning — the practical effect, the sound of vertebrae cracking, the priest's face — is the moment The Exorcist stopped being a horror film and became a cultural event. Friedkin shot possession the way he shot The French Connection's car chase: with a documentarian's refusal to aestheticize what the camera is seeing. The result is horror that feels witnessed rather than constructed. Craven's Elm Street is more inventive — the kills are wilder, the imagery more surreal — but invention at scale becomes spectacle, and spectacle is easier to process than testimony. The lead says testified horror outlasts spectacular horror. The film that feels like evidence beats the film that feels like a dream.

The Numbers

A Nightmare on Elm Street The Exorcist
Head-to-Head 32% 68%
Overall Win Rate 46% 58%
Championships 16 73
Avg Decision 2.7s 1.8s
Budget $2M $12M
Box Office $57M $441M

Where This Matchup Sits

Both sit mid-table among 42 Horror films on BingeBracket — similar genre standing.

When matched against other films, The Exorcist can handle The Texas Chainsaw Massacre but A Nightmare on Elm Street can't. What one film wins comfortably, the other loses.

The championship record tells the same story: The Exorcist has 73 tournament wins to A Nightmare on Elm Street's 16. The pedigree gap matches the head-to-head gap.

The Exorcist earned $441M on a $12M budget while A Nightmare on Elm Street made $57M on $2M. The bracket result tracks the money — The Exorcist wins both.