A Nightmare on Elm Street currently dominates The Shining 74–26
B-movie dream horror routs Kubrick's prestige nightmare.
The Verdict Neck and Neck
Craven made Elm Street for less than two million dollars and filled it with images Kubrick's forty-million-dollar Overlook never attempted — the body bag dragging itself down a school corridor, the phone made of tongue, Freddy's arms stretching to impossible length in an alley. Kubrick's horror is architectural and deliberate, every frame composed with a mathematician's patience. Craven's is feverish, cheap in places, and more frightening in its best moments because the images feel genuinely uncontrolled. At 74 to 26, voters are siding with horror that operates like an actual nightmare — chaotic, illogical, and impossible to prepare for — over horror that operates like a floor plan.
The Numbers
| A Nightmare on Elm Street | The Shining | |
|---|---|---|
| Head-to-Head | 74% | 26% |
| Overall Win Rate | 47% | 47% |
| Championships | 11 | 33 |
| Avg Decision | 0.9s | 1.7s |
| Budget | $2M | $19M |
| Box Office | $57M | $45M |
Where This Matchup Sits
Among 38 Horror films on BingeBracket, neither stands out — both land in similar territory.
Elsewhere on the platform, they have a common problem — Psycho beats both of them. Whatever else separates these two films, they share that one loss.
The Shining has 33 tournament wins to A Nightmare on Elm Street's 11, but that championship pedigree isn't translating to the head-to-head. Something about this specific pairing overrides the broader record.
The Shining is the higher-rated film on TMDB at 8.2 vs 7.3. Bracket voters keep choosing A Nightmare on Elm Street anyway — a sign that critical consensus and head-to-head instinct don't always point the same direction.
Think The Shining deserves better?
You're in the 26%.
Play the bracket these votes came from. Your pick shifts the result.
Want to pit A Nightmare on Elm Street against something else?
Build your own bracket with any films you want.