Raging Bull currently beats E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial 65–35

Scorsese’s punishment outweighs Spielberg’s comfort.

VS
35% 65%
Based on 40 head-to-head votes across 1 bracket

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Genre Clash

De Niro gained sixty pounds and Scorsese shot the boxing in black-and-white slow motion — each punch landing with a sound design that makes the audience flinch — because Raging Bull isn’t interested in making the violence look like anything other than what it is. E.T.’s Spielberg is interested in the opposite: making the impossible look like it could happen in your backyard. The bicycles, the Reese’s Pieces, the shed where a child hides an alien from the government. the film that refuses comfort is edging the one that offers it. In a Spielberg-Scorsese bracket, the audience that showed up knows both registers and is reaching for the harder one.

The Numbers

E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial Raging Bull
Head-to-Head 35% 65%
Overall Win Rate 41% 42%
Championships 19 17
Avg Decision 3.2s 2.9s
Budget $11M $18M
Box Office $797M $23M

Where This Matchup Sits

Among 25 films from the 1980s on BingeBracket, E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial languishing near the bottom and Raging Bull is in the bottom quarter.

Against shared opponents, Jaws splits them: Raging Bull wins that matchup comfortably, while E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial can't get past it.

Despite the lopsided head-to-head, the tournament records are competitive: E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial with 19 titles, Raging Bull with 17. The broader record is tighter than this specific matchup.

The box office gap is clear: $797M for E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, $23M for Raging Bull. But Raging Bull wins head-to-head despite earning less.