Raging Bull currently edges The Departed 54–46

De Niro's self-destruction outfights the Boston crime machine.

VS
46% 54%
Based on 54 head-to-head votes across 1 bracket

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Director's Cut

De Niro in the jail cell — punching the wall, head-butting the concrete, 'I'm not an animal' — is the scene that makes Raging Bull more than a boxing film. Scorsese builds two hours of escalating self-destruction toward a man turning the body that won fights into a weapon against itself. The Departed has the more complex plot. Raging Bull has the more devastating trajectory. The lead says a single devastating trajectory outperforms a complex architecture. De Niro's descent carries the film past Scorsese's own later brilliance.

The Numbers

The Departed Raging Bull
Head-to-Head 46% 54%
Overall Win Rate 57% 43%
Championships 61 17
Avg Decision 2.4s 2.8s
Budget $90M $18M
Return 3.2x 1.3x
The Twist

The Departed wins 57% of its matchups across BingeBracket, compared to 43% for Raging Bull. The overall record favours The Departed — but not in this head-to-head.

Where This Matchup Sits

BingeBracket tracks 101 Drama films — The Departed is in the top quarter, Raging Bull is in the lower half.

Among Martin Scorsese's 5 films on BingeBracket, The Departed sits at #3 and Raging Bull at #5.

Looking at shared opponents, Taxi Driver draws a line between them: The Departed dominates that matchup, but Raging Bull comes out on the wrong side.