The Dark Knight currently beats Oppenheimer 56–44

Dark Knight leads Oppenheimer. Nolan's superhero film edges his historical epic.

VS
56% 44%
Based on 43 head-to-head votes across 2 brackets

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Director's Cut

Both films are Nolan at full capacity, which makes the lead genuinely informative: the blockbuster is edging the prestige film. Dark Knight's advantage is concentrated in Ledger's Joker, the interrogation scene, a performance so overwhelming it restructured the entire superhero genre's ambitions. Oppenheimer's advantage is distributed across Murphy's restraint, Downey Jr.'s Strauss, the Trinity test, a film that trusts silence the way most blockbusters trust explosions. The narrow lead says concentration has a slight edge over distribution, but Oppenheimer's case is clearly landing. Nolan made his most popular film and his most respected film, and the popular one is winning by a margin that could close with more votes.

The Numbers

The Dark Knight Oppenheimer
Head-to-Head 56% 44%
Overall Win Rate 62% 55%
Championships 197 44
Avg Decision 3.5s 3.0s
Budget $185M $100M
Box Office $1.0B $952M

Where This Matchup Sits

Out of 111 Drama films on the platform, The Dark Knight at #7 and Oppenheimer is in the upper half.

Within Christopher Nolan's filmography on the platform, The Dark Knight at #2 and Oppenheimer at #5 out of 11.

When facing other films, Tenet loses to both of them on the platform. Whatever separates these two, they're both a clear step above that opponent.