The Witch currently dominates Us 76–24
Puritan restraint buries the Tethered — withholding overwhelms revelation.
The Verdict
Black Phillip doesn't speak until the final minutes. Until then, the goat is just a goat, the forest is just dark, the family's faith is just fracturing. Eggers trusts the wrongness to accumulate without explanation, and the payoff — "Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?" — lands because he withheld it for ninety minutes. Peele's Us operates in the opposite register: the Tethered arrive early, the mythology expands, the explanation comes whether you're ready or not. Nyong'o's dual performance is extraordinary, but the film around it insists on being decoded, and decoding diffuses dread. The formal gap is stark. The horror you can't quite explain stays longer than the horror that explains itself, and the gap suggests the difference is fundamental.
The Numbers
| The Witch | Us | |
|---|---|---|
| Head-to-Head | 76% | 24% |
| Overall Win Rate | 56% | 25% |
| Championships | 11 | 2 |
| Avg Decision | 2.7s | 2.6s |
| Budget | $4M | $20M |
| Box Office | $40M | $256M |
Where This Matchup Sits
Out of 38 Horror films on the platform, The Witch is in the upper half and Us languishing near the bottom.
Against other opponents, one pattern stands out: Get Out beats both of them. It's the one film that sits above this entire matchup.
The Witch with 11 titles and Us with 2 — the tournament record and the head-to-head point the same direction.
Us was the bigger hit commercially ($256M vs $40M), but The Witch wins head-to-head. Ticket sales and bracket instinct don't always agree.
Think Us deserves better?
You're in the 24%.
Play the bracket these 125 votes came from. Your pick shifts the result.
Where to Watch
Availability may vary by region.
Want to pit The Witch against something else?
Build your own bracket with any films you want.