The Witch currently edges Nosferatu 53–47

Eggers vs. Eggers, and neither wins.

VS
53% 47%
Based on 15 head-to-head votes across 1 bracket

Who do you think should win?

or

The Verdict Director's Cut

This matchup has 15 votes. The picture may shift as more people weigh in.

A split between The Witch and Nosferatu is a split between two versions of the same director — the one who builds from archival sources and the one who rebuilds from cinematic ones. Both are formally meticulous. Both demonstrate period commitment that borders on obsession. The Witch’s Puritan dread and Nosferatu’s Gothic romanticism are different registers of the same sensibility. neither the debut nor the adaptation is winning the argument. Eggers’s audience is genuinely divided on which mode suits him better: the original who builds his own mythology, or the inheritor who honours someone else’s. The tie says both modes are real.

The Numbers

The Witch Nosferatu
Head-to-Head 53% 47%
Overall Win Rate 54% 32%
Championships 34 21
Budget $4M $50M
Box Office $40M $182M

Where This Matchup Sits

Nosferatu struggles in Drama among 101 on BingeBracket.

Looking at Robert Eggers's 3 films on BingeBracket, The Witch ranks #1 and Nosferatu ranks #3.

Elsewhere on the platform, they have a common problem — Get Out beats both of them. Whatever else separates these two films, they share that one loss.

Nosferatu gets chosen fast (1.5s). The Witch gets chosen slowly (3.2s). Both choices are valid — they're just coming from different places.

Where to Watch

The Witch
Nosferatu

Availability may vary by region.

Want to pit The Witch against something else?

Build your own bracket with any films you want.